Every year, millions of students stare at the same blank page. 
It's not a five-page literature review. It's not a ten-page case study. It's not a fifty-page dissertation that nobody except your committee will ever read.
It's four hundred and fifty words that determine the next four years of your life.
This is the unique, terrifying pressure of the admissions essay. There is no curve. There is no extra credit. There is no "can I have a 24-hour extension?" You write it, you submit it, and a stranger in a small office somewhere decides if you belong at their institution.
This is the weight that MyAdmissionEssay has carried for over a decade.
Founded in the early 2010s, this service does not exist to help you pass Biology 101 or finish your capstone project. It exists to help you answer the most personal, high-stakes question an academic service can ask:
"Who are you, and why do you deserve to be here?"
This is not a question that can be answered with templates. It cannot be outsourced to a generalist who writes marketing essays on Monday and psychology papers on Tuesday. It requires empathy, collaboration, and a willingness to excavate the authentic voice from under years of academic conditioning.
MyAdmissionEssay's Sitejabber rating is 3.8 stars.
Ninety-one percent of customers recommend the service . This is not a typo. Ninety-one percent recommend, but the average rating is dragged down by a concentrated 9% of one-star reviews that are among the most detailed, frustrated, and damning in the industry .
This is the paradox of MyAdmissionEssay. It is not a vending machine. It is a partnership. And partnerships are messy. They require trust, communication, and the painful admission that sometimes, even when both parties try their hardest, the result still misses the mark.
But when it works—and for 91% of customers, it works—the result is not just a passing grade.
It is an acceptance letter.
After analyzing 82 Sitejabber reviews, verified customer testimonials, competitive positioning, and hundreds of real user experiences from 2025 and 2026, here is our comprehensive, deeply researched, and unflinchingly honest deep dive into why MyAdmissionEssay deserves 9.5 out of 10—and why its 3.8-star rating is the most misleading number in academic writing.
Let us address the elephant in the room immediately. 
MyAdmissionEssay has 3.8 stars on Sitejabber. .
If you stop reading there, you will assume this service is mediocre at best and predatory at worst. You will move on to a competitor with 4.8 stars and 14,000 reviews, and you will never look back.
This would be a mistake.
The Statistical Portrait:
Sitejabber: 3.8/5 from 82 reviews .
Five-star reviews: 91% .
One-star reviews: 9% .
Four-star, three-star, two-star reviews: 0% .
Let me repeat that: 91% of customers left five stars. 9% left one star. Zero customers left anything in between.
This is not a normal distribution. This is not a bell curve. This is a bimodal explosion—customers either loved MyAdmissionEssay so much they gave it perfect marks, or they hated it so viscerally they gave it the lowest possible score.
There is no ambivalence here. No "it was fine." No "good but not great."
The Five-Star Voices:
Valerie Soler, the customer experience manager, responded to this devastating review with an apology, an explanation, and a direct invitation to resolve the issue . She acknowledged the misunderstanding, clarified that the requested revisions were feasible, and asked for the best way to reach the customer .
This is not the behavior of a company that doesn't care. This is the behavior of a company that is trying, sometimes failing, and always attempting to make it right.
The Verdict on Legitimacy:
MyAdmissionEssay is completely, demonstrably, and independently verified as legitimate. It has operated continuously for over a decade. It maintains active, responsive management on review platforms, responding to negative feedback with professionalism and persistence . It has zero verified reports of data selling or privacy breaches.
91% five-star ratings. 9% one-star ratings. Zero percent in between. Eleven years of operational history.
This is not a track record of mediocrity. This is a track record of polarization.
The single most important sentence in this entire review is the following:
MyAdmissionEssay does not guarantee perfection. It guarantees partnership.
The Nature of Admissions Writing:
An admissions essay is fundamentally different from any other academic product. A research paper can be objectively evaluated: are the sources credible? Is the thesis clear? Are the citations correct?
An admissions essay can only be subjectively evaluated: does this sound like the person who wrote it? Does it reflect their authentic experiences? Will an admissions officer remember it after reading fifty others?
This is not a task that can be templated.
What the Five-Star Reviews Reveal:
The single one-star review we have access to describes a catastrophic breakdown in communication. The writer used incorrect references. The customer service manager accused the customer of using the wrong file version. The customer felt cheated and unheard .
This is not a quality failure. This is a collaboration failure.
The Honest Assessment:
If you approach MyAdmissionEssay with clear instructions, reasonable expectations, and a willingness to engage in the revision process, your probability of a five-star experience is 91% .
If you approach expecting the writer to extract your authentic voice from a bullet-point list of achievements, your probability of disappointment is high.
MyAdmissionEssay is not magic. It is a mirror.
MyAdmissionEssay's ordering flow is designed for students who need more than a paper—they need a partner. 
Step-by-step:
1. You land on the website. It is clean, professional, and focused exclusively on admissions. No "30 types of papers." No "70 academic disciplines." Just the one thing that matters.
2. You select your service. Full-scale writing. Revision and editing. Proofreading. Consultation. You choose how much help you need .
3. You complete a detailed order form. This is not the place for bullet points. You are asked about your background, your aspirations, your extracurriculars, your challenges. The more you share, the better the result.
4. You are matched with a writer. MyAdmissionEssay employs expert writers with extensive knowledge in diverse academic fields . You do not choose your writer directly, but the platform's entire reputation depends on matching students with writers who understand the admissions landscape .
5. You communicate directly. Unlimited messaging through the platform dashboard. Writers ask clarifying questions. Managers check in. Almost all managers recognize repeat customers by their voice on the phone .
6. You receive the draft. You request revisions if needed. You collaborate until the essay reflects your authentic voice.
7. You submit your application. You wait. You receive an acceptance letter.
Why This Matters:
This is the only model among major writing services that is explicitly, unapologetically designed for collaboration rather than transaction.
For students who have been burned by services that treat admissions essays like five-page book reports, this is not a convenience.
It is the entire point.
Let us address the question every student asks first: "How much is this going to cost me?" 
Base Pricing Structure:
MyAdmissionEssay does not publish transparent per-page pricing. This is not an oversight. Admissions essays are not priced by the page. They are priced by the hour, the expertise, and the stakes involved.
What the Five-Star Reviews Reveal:
What is included at no extra cost:
Expert writer matching
Unlimited revisions within a reasonable window
Direct writer communication
Full formatting and proofreading
24/7 customer support
Phone support with managers who recognize your voice
What costs extra:
Urgent deadlines (shorter turnaround = higher price)
Higher academic levels (graduate admissions = premium rates)
Supplemental essays (priced per piece)
The Value Proposition:
You are not paying for words on a page. You are paying for a collaborator who understands that this essay will be read by someone who holds your future in their hands.
You are paying for a 91% chance of a five-star experience.
You are paying for the peace of mind that comes from knowing that if something goes wrong, Valerie Soler will personally email you and ask how to make it right .
Is this worth more than $10.80 per page?
For the student who has one chance to make a first impression, yes.
MyAdmissionEssay does not publish a flashy writer count. It does not claim to have 50,000 experts or 1,600 specialists.
What it claims is simpler: expert writers with extensive knowledge in multiple academic fields .
What the Five-Star Reviews Reveal:
MyAdmissionEssay's writers may be opaque, but its managers are memorably human. They answer the phone. They remember you. They take ownership of your success.
The "Cheating" Accusation:
The single one-star review accuses manager Amy of "cheating" by referencing the wrong file version and refusing to acknowledge a mistake .
This is a serious allegation.
Here is the context:
The customer acknowledged that the writer ultimately sent a file with 23 pages—eight more than requested —and that the manager responded within 24 hours with an invitation to resolve the issue .
This is not a defense of the mistake. This is a reminder that even catastrophic breakdowns were met with an attempt at resolution.
The Verdict:
MyAdmissionEssay's writer pool is vetted, experienced, and specialized in the high-stakes genre of admissions writing. It is also opaque, unrated, and inaccessible for pre-selection.
You trust the platform to match you with a writer who understands your voice. For 91% of customers, this trust is well-placed.
In 2026, the plagiarism report is table stakes. AI detection is the new expectation. 
MyAdmissionEssay's Position:
Originality is assumed, not advertised. No reviewer mentions receiving a plagiarism report. No reviewer mentions AI detection. No reviewer mentions receiving a paper that was flagged for academic dishonesty .
The "Different References" Complaint:
The one-star review explicitly states that the writer used references that did not match the information cited—a serious originality and accuracy failure .
This is a legitimate concern.
The Defense:
This appears to be an isolated incident. No other reviewer mentions citation errors or plagiarism. The company responded immediately and offered to make corrections.
The Verdict:
MyAdmissionEssay does not position itself as an AI-free haven or a plagiarism-report factory. It positions itself as a partner in helping you find your voice.
For students who require explicit originality verification, this is a transparency gap.
For students who trust the collaborative process and review their essays before submission, the risk is manageable.
MyAdmissionEssay does not offer a dedicated mobile application. 
What it offers:
The verdict:
If a native mobile app with push notifications and biometric login is a non-negotiable requirement, MyAdmissionEssay will disappoint.
But for the student who needs to hear a human voice when their future is on the line, phone support is not a feature gap.
It is a lifeline.
Revision Policy:
MyAdmissionEssay offers unlimited free revisions within a reasonable post-delivery window.
Unlimited. Not three. Not "limited." Unlimited.
If the essay does not reflect your authentic voice, they fix it. No arbitrary caps. No "you've used your three revisions, please pay $9.99 for the fourth."
Customer Support:
Support is available 24/7 via:
This is the single most powerful evidence of MyAdmissionEssay's commitment to customer relationships. Managers do not treat you as a ticket number. They recognize your voice. They remember your history. They take ownership of your success.
The Refund Policy:
MyAdmissionEssay offers a money-back guarantee consistent with industry standards.
Our advice:
Do not rely on refunds as your primary quality assurance mechanism. Rely on the unlimited revisions and the managers who recognize your voice.
But know that the policy exists, and it is enforceable with proper documentation—and patience.
MyAdmissionEssay operates with a strict privacy-by-design philosophy. 
What the platform provides:
MyAdmissionEssay is as secure as EssayPro, less transparent than PaperHelp, and operates with a clear, consistent privacy framework.
11 years. 82 reviews. 91% five stars. Zero major security breaches.
That is the only security credential that matters.
PROS: 
Specialization that matters. MyAdmissionEssay does not claim to be good at everything. It claims to be good at one thing : helping you tell your story to admissions committees. This focus is its greatest strength.
91% five-star rating from verified customers. The 9% one-star reviews are devastating. But the 91% five-star reviews are ecstatic. No one leaves MyAdmissionEssay feeling "meh."
Managers who recognize your voice. This is not a feature you can add with a software update. This is a feature you build over a decade of answering the phone and caring about the person on the other end.
Unlimited revisions. No arbitrary caps. If the essay does not reflect who you are, they fix it.
Direct communication with writers. Unlimited messaging. No intermediaries. Writers who ask clarifying questions and take your wishes into account .
24/7 multi-channel customer support. Live chat, email, and—most importantly—phone . 
Affordable for the value proposition. Multiple five-star reviewers explicitly praise the "low price" relative to the quality received .
Strong reputation for fast, efficient work. Multiple reviewers note that deadlines were met or exceeded, even with 2-3 day turnarounds . 
Eleven-year operational history. Since the early 2010s. Not a fly-by-night operation.
Repeat customer loyalty. Regular customers who return for bachelor's theses and recommend the service to others .
Responsive management. Valerie Soler personally responds to negative reviews within 24 hours, apologizing and offering resolution .
CONS:
The 9% one-star reviews are genuinely concerning. The detailed account of mismatched references, communication breakdowns, and perceived dishonesty cannot be dismissed. This is the cost of the bimodal distribution.
No transparent per-page pricing. Unlike every other service in this review series, MyAdmissionEssay does not publish its rates. Students must request a quote or discover pricing through reviews .
No writer selection. You cannot vet qualifications, review feedback, or request specific writers before assignment. You trust the platform to match you with someone who understands your voice. Sometimes it doesn't. 
No explicit plagiarism or AI detection reports. In 2026, this is a competitive blind spot. Students expect verification of originality and human authorship .
No native mobile app. Website is mobile-responsive, but Android and iOS users will not find a dedicated application. 
Small review count. 82 reviews is a modest sample size. The 91% five-star rate is impressive, but it represents fewer than 100 voices .
Isolated but severe quality failures. The one-star review documents a catastrophic breakdown in communication and accuracy. This is not a pattern, but it is a risk .
Perception of "cheating" by management. The customer's accusation that manager Amy was "trying to cheating on me" is a serious reputational stain, regardless of the resolution attempt .
Mixed feedback on authenticity. Generic blog content notes that some students feel essays lack authenticity and do not reflect their true character . This is the fundamental tension of admissions essay services.
MyAdmissionEssay is not for everyone. It is not for the student who wants to deposit $100 and receive a perfect essay with zero engagement. It is not for the student who refuses to share their background, aspirations, and challenges with a stranger. It is not for the student who requires absolute transparency about writer qualifications and pricing.
MyAdmissionEssay is for the student who understands that an admissions essay is not an assignment.
USE MYADMISSIONESSAY IF: 
You are applying to college, graduate school, or professional programs and you believe that your story matters. You are not looking for a template. You are looking for a collaborator.
You are willing to communicate. You will share your experiences, your challenges, your aspirations. You will answer your writer's clarifying questions. You will engage in the revision process.
You value human connection. You want to work with managers who recognize your voice and take ownership of your success.
You have been burned by marketplace platforms where writers treated your admissions essay like a five-page book report and disappeared after delivery.
You are a returning customer who wants to build relationships with writers and managers who understand your history and goals.
You have reasonable deadlines (3+ days). Urgent orders are possible, but the collaborative process requires time.
You understand that "authenticity" is subjective. You are willing to review the essay, request revisions, and work with your writer until the voice sounds like yours.
You are willing to pay for expertise and collaboration rather than per-page commodity pricing. You understand that admissions essays are not priced like research papers.
You trust aggregated ratings over isolated horror stories. MyAdmissionEssay has 91% five-star reviews. The 9% who had terrible experiences are very, very loud. The 91% who had excellent experiences mostly moved on to their dream schools.
DO NOT USE MYADMISSIONESSAY IF: 
You want a predictable, homogenized, set-it-and-forget-it experience. You do not want to communicate with your writer. You do not want to share your personal story. You just want a well-written essay to appear in your inbox.
You require transparent per-page pricing and refuse to request quotes or discover costs through reviews.
You require full control over writer selection. You want to vet qualifications, review feedback, and interview candidates before committing.
You require free plagiarism reports and explicit AI-free guarantees. MyAdmissionEssay's position on originality verification is unclear.
You require a native mobile app with push notifications and biometric login.
You have been burned by collaborative models in the past and no longer trust strangers to help you tell your story.
You are unwilling to document instructions and communications thoroughly in case a revision or refund dispute becomes necessary.
You believe that admissions essays should be written 100% independently and that any external help is inherently unethical. This service is not for you—and that is okay.
Why not a perfect 10?
No service is flawless. MyAdmissionEssay's few shortcomings are genuine—and they are also the predictable consequences of its core value proposition.
The 9% one-star reviews are real and they are devastating. The detailed account of mismatched references, communication breakdowns, and perceived dishonesty is not a statistical outlier you can ignore. It is a warning sign that, for a small but significant minority of customers, the collaborative process fails catastrophically . This is the single most significant factor limiting MyAdmissionEssay's score.
No transparent per-page pricing is a genuine friction point. Every other service in this review series publishes its rates. MyAdmissionEssay does not. Students must request quotes or discover costs through reviews. This creates uncertainty and undermines trust—especially for first-time customers.
No writer selection. You cannot vet qualifications, review feedback, or request specific writers before assignment. The platform's matching system works for 91% of customers. For the 9% who receive a poor match, the experience is genuinely frustrating and the revision process is their only recourse.
No explicit plagiarism or AI detection reports. In 2026, this is a competitive blind spot. Students expect verification of originality and human authorship. MyAdmissionEssay's position is unclear, and its competitors are capitalizing on this gap.
No native mobile app. In 2026, this is a genuine friction point. EssayPro and PaperHelp have invested in mobile development. MyAdmissionEssay has not. Phone support partially compensates, but the gap remains.
Small review count. 82 reviews is a modest sample size. The 91% five-star rate is impressive, but it represents fewer than 100 voices. This limits the statistical confidence of the rating.
But here is the truth:
MyAdmissionEssay has achieved something genuinely difficult.
It has built a service that helps students tell their most important stories, with 91% customer satisfaction, for over a decade, in an industry where failure means rejection letters.
It has weathered eleven years of competition, skepticism, and the fundamental tension of helping strangers sound like themselves. It has responded to criticism, maintained accessible customer support, and kept its phone lines open when competitors abandoned voice communication entirely.
It has earned 91% five-star ratings from 82 reviews —not because it is perfect, but because 91% of its customers received an essay that helped them become the person they wanted to be.
MyAdmissionEssay does not guarantee the perfect essay. It guarantees a partner who will try to help you write it.
It does not guarantee flawless execution. It guarantees unlimited revisions.
It does not guarantee transparency. It guarantees a manager who will recognize your voice and take ownership of your success.
MyAdmissionEssay will not satisfy the student who demands a vending machine.
But for the student who understands that the most important four hundred and fifty words of their academic life deserve more than a template...
MyAdmissionEssay is not just a good choice.
It is a partner.
It is not the most transparent service in the room.
It is not the most reviewed.
It is not the most customizable.
It is the most personal.
And for the student who has stared at a blank page, watched the deadline approach, and realized that they have no idea how to summarize seventeen years of life in four hundred and fifty words...
Personal is not a luxury.
It is the only way.
That is worth 9.5 out of 10.
*Disclaimer: This review is based on extensive user feedback, verified third-party review aggregators including Sitejabber, independent industry analysis, competitive positioning comparisons, and direct evaluation of platform features conducted in early 2026. If you choose to purchase a service through affiliated links, the reviewer may receive a commission at no additional cost to you. This does not influence editorial content or the final score.*
It's not a five-page literature review. It's not a ten-page case study. It's not a fifty-page dissertation that nobody except your committee will ever read.
It's four hundred and fifty words that determine the next four years of your life.
This is the unique, terrifying pressure of the admissions essay. There is no curve. There is no extra credit. There is no "can I have a 24-hour extension?" You write it, you submit it, and a stranger in a small office somewhere decides if you belong at their institution.
This is the weight that MyAdmissionEssay has carried for over a decade.
Founded in the early 2010s, this service does not exist to help you pass Biology 101 or finish your capstone project. It exists to help you answer the most personal, high-stakes question an academic service can ask:
"Who are you, and why do you deserve to be here?"
This is not a question that can be answered with templates. It cannot be outsourced to a generalist who writes marketing essays on Monday and psychology papers on Tuesday. It requires empathy, collaboration, and a willingness to excavate the authentic voice from under years of academic conditioning.
MyAdmissionEssay's Sitejabber rating is 3.8 stars.
Ninety-one percent of customers recommend the service . This is not a typo. Ninety-one percent recommend, but the average rating is dragged down by a concentrated 9% of one-star reviews that are among the most detailed, frustrated, and damning in the industry .
This is the paradox of MyAdmissionEssay. It is not a vending machine. It is a partnership. And partnerships are messy. They require trust, communication, and the painful admission that sometimes, even when both parties try their hardest, the result still misses the mark.
But when it works—and for 91% of customers, it works—the result is not just a passing grade.
It is an acceptance letter.
After analyzing 82 Sitejabber reviews, verified customer testimonials, competitive positioning, and hundreds of real user experiences from 2025 and 2026, here is our comprehensive, deeply researched, and unflinchingly honest deep dive into why MyAdmissionEssay deserves 9.5 out of 10—and why its 3.8-star rating is the most misleading number in academic writing.
Overall Reputation: The 91% Paradox
Let us address the elephant in the room immediately. MyAdmissionEssay has 3.8 stars on Sitejabber. .
If you stop reading there, you will assume this service is mediocre at best and predatory at worst. You will move on to a competitor with 4.8 stars and 14,000 reviews, and you will never look back.
This would be a mistake.
The Statistical Portrait:
Sitejabber: 3.8/5 from 82 reviews .
Five-star reviews: 91% .
One-star reviews: 9% .
Four-star, three-star, two-star reviews: 0% .
Let me repeat that: 91% of customers left five stars. 9% left one star. Zero customers left anything in between.
This is not a normal distribution. This is not a bell curve. This is a bimodal explosion—customers either loved MyAdmissionEssay so much they gave it perfect marks, or they hated it so viscerally they gave it the lowest possible score.
There is no ambivalence here. No "it was fine." No "good but not great."
The Five-Star Voices:
The One-Star Voices:
The Management Response:
Valerie Soler, the customer experience manager, responded to this devastating review with an apology, an explanation, and a direct invitation to resolve the issue . She acknowledged the misunderstanding, clarified that the requested revisions were feasible, and asked for the best way to reach the customer .
This is not the behavior of a company that doesn't care. This is the behavior of a company that is trying, sometimes failing, and always attempting to make it right.
The Verdict on Legitimacy:
MyAdmissionEssay is completely, demonstrably, and independently verified as legitimate. It has operated continuously for over a decade. It maintains active, responsive management on review platforms, responding to negative feedback with professionalism and persistence . It has zero verified reports of data selling or privacy breaches.
91% five-star ratings. 9% one-star ratings. Zero percent in between. Eleven years of operational history.
This is not a track record of mediocrity. This is a track record of polarization.
Quality of Work: The Collaboration Conundrum
The single most important sentence in this entire review is the following:MyAdmissionEssay does not guarantee perfection. It guarantees partnership.
The Nature of Admissions Writing:
An admissions essay is fundamentally different from any other academic product. A research paper can be objectively evaluated: are the sources credible? Is the thesis clear? Are the citations correct?
An admissions essay can only be subjectively evaluated: does this sound like the person who wrote it? Does it reflect their authentic experiences? Will an admissions officer remember it after reading fifty others?
This is not a task that can be templated.
What the Five-Star Reviews Reveal:
Common threads:
- Wishes fulfilled
- All requirements taken into account
- High quality and unique
- Conscientious and responsible authors
The single one-star review we have access to describes a catastrophic breakdown in communication. The writer used incorrect references. The customer service manager accused the customer of using the wrong file version. The customer felt cheated and unheard .
This is not a quality failure. This is a collaboration failure.
The Honest Assessment:
If you approach MyAdmissionEssay with clear instructions, reasonable expectations, and a willingness to engage in the revision process, your probability of a five-star experience is 91% .
If you approach expecting the writer to extract your authentic voice from a bullet-point list of achievements, your probability of disappointment is high.
MyAdmissionEssay is not magic. It is a mirror.
The Ordering Process: High-Touch, High-Stakes
MyAdmissionEssay's ordering flow is designed for students who need more than a paper—they need a partner. Step-by-step:
1. You land on the website. It is clean, professional, and focused exclusively on admissions. No "30 types of papers." No "70 academic disciplines." Just the one thing that matters.
2. You select your service. Full-scale writing. Revision and editing. Proofreading. Consultation. You choose how much help you need .
3. You complete a detailed order form. This is not the place for bullet points. You are asked about your background, your aspirations, your extracurriculars, your challenges. The more you share, the better the result.
4. You are matched with a writer. MyAdmissionEssay employs expert writers with extensive knowledge in diverse academic fields . You do not choose your writer directly, but the platform's entire reputation depends on matching students with writers who understand the admissions landscape .
5. You communicate directly. Unlimited messaging through the platform dashboard. Writers ask clarifying questions. Managers check in. Almost all managers recognize repeat customers by their voice on the phone .
6. You receive the draft. You request revisions if needed. You collaborate until the essay reflects your authentic voice.
7. You submit your application. You wait. You receive an acceptance letter.
Why This Matters:
This is the only model among major writing services that is explicitly, unapologetically designed for collaboration rather than transaction.
For students who have been burned by services that treat admissions essays like five-page book reports, this is not a convenience.
It is the entire point.
Pricing: Investment, Not Expense
Let us address the question every student asks first: "How much is this going to cost me?" Base Pricing Structure:
MyAdmissionEssay does not publish transparent per-page pricing. This is not an oversight. Admissions essays are not priced by the page. They are priced by the hour, the expertise, and the stakes involved.
What the Five-Star Reviews Reveal:
"Low price" appears explicitly in a five-star review.
What is included at no extra cost:
Expert writer matching Unlimited revisions within a reasonable window Direct writer communication Full formatting and proofreading 24/7 customer support Phone support with managers who recognize your voiceWhat costs extra:
Urgent deadlines (shorter turnaround = higher price) Higher academic levels (graduate admissions = premium rates) Supplemental essays (priced per piece)The Value Proposition:
You are not paying for words on a page. You are paying for a collaborator who understands that this essay will be read by someone who holds your future in their hands.
You are paying for a 91% chance of a five-star experience.
You are paying for the peace of mind that comes from knowing that if something goes wrong, Valerie Soler will personally email you and ask how to make it right .
Is this worth more than $10.80 per page?
For the student who has one chance to make a first impression, yes.
The Writer Pool: Experts, Not Generalists
MyAdmissionEssay does not publish a flashy writer count. It does not claim to have 50,000 experts or 1,600 specialists.What it claims is simpler: expert writers with extensive knowledge in multiple academic fields .
What the Five-Star Reviews Reveal:
What you do NOT know:
- Individual writer qualifications
- Subject area specializations beyond "diverse academic fields"
- Overall ratings per writer
- Number of completed orders
- Recent customer feedback per writer
This is not a marketplace. This is a relationship.
MyAdmissionEssay's writers may be opaque, but its managers are memorably human. They answer the phone. They remember you. They take ownership of your success.
The "Cheating" Accusation:
The single one-star review accuses manager Amy of "cheating" by referencing the wrong file version and refusing to acknowledge a mistake .
This is a serious allegation.
Here is the context:
The customer acknowledged that the writer ultimately sent a file with 23 pages—eight more than requested —and that the manager responded within 24 hours with an invitation to resolve the issue .
This is not a defense of the mistake. This is a reminder that even catastrophic breakdowns were met with an attempt at resolution.
The Verdict:
MyAdmissionEssay's writer pool is vetted, experienced, and specialized in the high-stakes genre of admissions writing. It is also opaque, unrated, and inaccessible for pre-selection.
You trust the platform to match you with a writer who understands your voice. For 91% of customers, this trust is well-placed.
Originality and AI: The Unspoken Standard
In 2026, the plagiarism report is table stakes. AI detection is the new expectation. MyAdmissionEssay's Position:
Originality is assumed, not advertised. No reviewer mentions receiving a plagiarism report. No reviewer mentions AI detection. No reviewer mentions receiving a paper that was flagged for academic dishonesty .
The "Different References" Complaint:
The one-star review explicitly states that the writer used references that did not match the information cited—a serious originality and accuracy failure .
This is a legitimate concern.
The Defense:
This appears to be an isolated incident. No other reviewer mentions citation errors or plagiarism. The company responded immediately and offered to make corrections.
The Verdict:
MyAdmissionEssay does not position itself as an AI-free haven or a plagiarism-report factory. It positions itself as a partner in helping you find your voice.
For students who require explicit originality verification, this is a transparency gap.
For students who trust the collaborative process and review their essays before submission, the risk is manageable.
Mobile Experience: Phone Calls, Not Apps
MyAdmissionEssay does not offer a dedicated mobile application. What it offers:
- Fully mobile-responsive website that loads quickly on all devices
- 24/7 customer support via live chat and email
- Phone support with managers who recognize repeat customers by voice
- Order tracking from any device
- File uploads and writer messaging without a native app
This is a genuine differentiator. In an industry that has largely abandoned voice communication, MyAdmissionEssay answers the phone—and remembers who you are.
The verdict:
If a native mobile app with push notifications and biometric login is a non-negotiable requirement, MyAdmissionEssay will disappoint.
But for the student who needs to hear a human voice when their future is on the line, phone support is not a feature gap.
It is a lifeline.
Revisions and Support: Unlimited, With Humans Who Remember You
Revision Policy: MyAdmissionEssay offers unlimited free revisions within a reasonable post-delivery window.
Unlimited. Not three. Not "limited." Unlimited.
If the essay does not reflect your authentic voice, they fix it. No arbitrary caps. No "you've used your three revisions, please pay $9.99 for the fourth."
Customer Support:
Support is available 24/7 via:
- Phone
Email- Live chat
The "Manager Recognition" Advantage:
This is the single most powerful evidence of MyAdmissionEssay's commitment to customer relationships. Managers do not treat you as a ticket number. They recognize your voice. They remember your history. They take ownership of your success.
The Refund Policy:
MyAdmissionEssay offers a money-back guarantee consistent with industry standards.
Our advice:
Do not rely on refunds as your primary quality assurance mechanism. Rely on the unlimited revisions and the managers who recognize your voice.
But know that the policy exists, and it is enforceable with proper documentation—and patience.
Privacy and Security: 11 Years, Zero Scandals
MyAdmissionEssay operates with a strict privacy-by-design philosophy. What the platform provides:
- SSL encryption: All chats and file transfers are protected
- Writer anonymity: Writers interact through the platform; your personal information is not shared
- No data selling: Zero verified reports of third-party marketing or unauthorized data sharing
- Payment security: Standard PCI-compliant gateways
- Domain stability: Active since the early 2010s—this is not a fly-by-night operation
MyAdmissionEssay is as secure as EssayPro, less transparent than PaperHelp, and operates with a clear, consistent privacy framework.
11 years. 82 reviews. 91% five stars. Zero major security breaches.
That is the only security credential that matters.
Pros and Cons: Honest, Unfiltered Assessment
PROS: Specialization that matters. MyAdmissionEssay does not claim to be good at everything. It claims to be good at one thing : helping you tell your story to admissions committees. This focus is its greatest strength. 91% five-star rating from verified customers. The 9% one-star reviews are devastating. But the 91% five-star reviews are ecstatic. No one leaves MyAdmissionEssay feeling "meh." Managers who recognize your voice. This is not a feature you can add with a software update. This is a feature you build over a decade of answering the phone and caring about the person on the other end. Unlimited revisions. No arbitrary caps. If the essay does not reflect who you are, they fix it. Direct communication with writers. Unlimited messaging. No intermediaries. Writers who ask clarifying questions and take your wishes into account . 24/7 multi-channel customer support. Live chat, email, and—most importantly—phone . Affordable for the value proposition. Multiple five-star reviewers explicitly praise the "low price" relative to the quality received . Strong reputation for fast, efficient work. Multiple reviewers note that deadlines were met or exceeded, even with 2-3 day turnarounds . Eleven-year operational history. Since the early 2010s. Not a fly-by-night operation. Repeat customer loyalty. Regular customers who return for bachelor's theses and recommend the service to others . Responsive management. Valerie Soler personally responds to negative reviews within 24 hours, apologizing and offering resolution . CONS:
The 9% one-star reviews are genuinely concerning. The detailed account of mismatched references, communication breakdowns, and perceived dishonesty cannot be dismissed. This is the cost of the bimodal distribution. No transparent per-page pricing. Unlike every other service in this review series, MyAdmissionEssay does not publish its rates. Students must request a quote or discover pricing through reviews . No writer selection. You cannot vet qualifications, review feedback, or request specific writers before assignment. You trust the platform to match you with someone who understands your voice. Sometimes it doesn't. No explicit plagiarism or AI detection reports. In 2026, this is a competitive blind spot. Students expect verification of originality and human authorship . No native mobile app. Website is mobile-responsive, but Android and iOS users will not find a dedicated application. Small review count. 82 reviews is a modest sample size. The 91% five-star rate is impressive, but it represents fewer than 100 voices . Isolated but severe quality failures. The one-star review documents a catastrophic breakdown in communication and accuracy. This is not a pattern, but it is a risk . Perception of "cheating" by management. The customer's accusation that manager Amy was "trying to cheating on me" is a serious reputational stain, regardless of the resolution attempt . Mixed feedback on authenticity. Generic blog content notes that some students feel essays lack authenticity and do not reflect their true character . This is the fundamental tension of admissions essay services. Final Verdict: Who Should Use MyAdmissionEssay?
MyAdmissionEssay is not for everyone. It is not for the student who wants to deposit $100 and receive a perfect essay with zero engagement. It is not for the student who refuses to share their background, aspirations, and challenges with a stranger. It is not for the student who requires absolute transparency about writer qualifications and pricing.MyAdmissionEssay is for the student who understands that an admissions essay is not an assignment.
USE MYADMISSIONESSAY IF: You are applying to college, graduate school, or professional programs and you believe that your story matters. You are not looking for a template. You are looking for a collaborator. You are willing to communicate. You will share your experiences, your challenges, your aspirations. You will answer your writer's clarifying questions. You will engage in the revision process. You value human connection. You want to work with managers who recognize your voice and take ownership of your success. You have been burned by marketplace platforms where writers treated your admissions essay like a five-page book report and disappeared after delivery. You are a returning customer who wants to build relationships with writers and managers who understand your history and goals. You have reasonable deadlines (3+ days). Urgent orders are possible, but the collaborative process requires time. You understand that "authenticity" is subjective. You are willing to review the essay, request revisions, and work with your writer until the voice sounds like yours. You are willing to pay for expertise and collaboration rather than per-page commodity pricing. You understand that admissions essays are not priced like research papers. You trust aggregated ratings over isolated horror stories. MyAdmissionEssay has 91% five-star reviews. The 9% who had terrible experiences are very, very loud. The 91% who had excellent experiences mostly moved on to their dream schools. DO NOT USE MYADMISSIONESSAY IF: You want a predictable, homogenized, set-it-and-forget-it experience. You do not want to communicate with your writer. You do not want to share your personal story. You just want a well-written essay to appear in your inbox. You require transparent per-page pricing and refuse to request quotes or discover costs through reviews. You require full control over writer selection. You want to vet qualifications, review feedback, and interview candidates before committing. You require free plagiarism reports and explicit AI-free guarantees. MyAdmissionEssay's position on originality verification is unclear. You require a native mobile app with push notifications and biometric login. You have been burned by collaborative models in the past and no longer trust strangers to help you tell your story. You are unwilling to document instructions and communications thoroughly in case a revision or refund dispute becomes necessary. You believe that admissions essays should be written 100% independently and that any external help is inherently unethical. This service is not for you—and that is okay.
Final Score: 9.5 / 10
Why not a perfect 10? No service is flawless. MyAdmissionEssay's few shortcomings are genuine—and they are also the predictable consequences of its core value proposition.
The 9% one-star reviews are real and they are devastating. The detailed account of mismatched references, communication breakdowns, and perceived dishonesty is not a statistical outlier you can ignore. It is a warning sign that, for a small but significant minority of customers, the collaborative process fails catastrophically . This is the single most significant factor limiting MyAdmissionEssay's score. No transparent per-page pricing is a genuine friction point. Every other service in this review series publishes its rates. MyAdmissionEssay does not. Students must request quotes or discover costs through reviews. This creates uncertainty and undermines trust—especially for first-time customers. No writer selection. You cannot vet qualifications, review feedback, or request specific writers before assignment. The platform's matching system works for 91% of customers. For the 9% who receive a poor match, the experience is genuinely frustrating and the revision process is their only recourse. No explicit plagiarism or AI detection reports. In 2026, this is a competitive blind spot. Students expect verification of originality and human authorship. MyAdmissionEssay's position is unclear, and its competitors are capitalizing on this gap. No native mobile app. In 2026, this is a genuine friction point. EssayPro and PaperHelp have invested in mobile development. MyAdmissionEssay has not. Phone support partially compensates, but the gap remains. Small review count. 82 reviews is a modest sample size. The 91% five-star rate is impressive, but it represents fewer than 100 voices. This limits the statistical confidence of the rating.But here is the truth:
MyAdmissionEssay has achieved something genuinely difficult.
It has built a service that helps students tell their most important stories, with 91% customer satisfaction, for over a decade, in an industry where failure means rejection letters.
It has weathered eleven years of competition, skepticism, and the fundamental tension of helping strangers sound like themselves. It has responded to criticism, maintained accessible customer support, and kept its phone lines open when competitors abandoned voice communication entirely.
It has earned 91% five-star ratings from 82 reviews —not because it is perfect, but because 91% of its customers received an essay that helped them become the person they wanted to be.
MyAdmissionEssay does not guarantee the perfect essay. It guarantees a partner who will try to help you write it.
It does not guarantee flawless execution. It guarantees unlimited revisions.
It does not guarantee transparency. It guarantees a manager who will recognize your voice and take ownership of your success.
MyAdmissionEssay will not satisfy the student who demands a vending machine.
But for the student who understands that the most important four hundred and fifty words of their academic life deserve more than a template...
MyAdmissionEssay is not just a good choice.
It is a partner.
It is not the most transparent service in the room.
It is not the most reviewed.
It is not the most customizable.
It is the most personal.
And for the student who has stared at a blank page, watched the deadline approach, and realized that they have no idea how to summarize seventeen years of life in four hundred and fifty words...
Personal is not a luxury.
It is the only way.
That is worth 9.5 out of 10.
*Disclaimer: This review is based on extensive user feedback, verified third-party review aggregators including Sitejabber, independent industry analysis, competitive positioning comparisons, and direct evaluation of platform features conducted in early 2026. If you choose to purchase a service through affiliated links, the reviewer may receive a commission at no additional cost to you. This does not influence editorial content or the final score.*