PetraWice
New member
- Joined
- Feb 19, 2026
- Messages
- 12
Hey everyone! I'm the type of person who researches everything to death before spending money. 
When I was applying to colleges last year, I spent weeks (maybe too many weeks) comparing the best college application essay writing services because I wanted to make sure I didn't waste my有限的 budget.
I tried a few different approaches and wanted to share what I learned for anyone currently in the trenches:
Type 1: Big Platforms with Mystery Writers
Some of the large services I tried felt like a factory. I uploaded my essay, got edits back from someone I never met, and the comments felt generic. "Great point here!" without any real guidance. The price was low ($50-$100), but the value was low too. You get what you pay for.
Type 2: Individual Consultants with Real Experience
This was a game-changer. I found consultants who had actually worked in admissions offices or were professional writers . Yes, it was more expensive (think $200-$500 depending on the package), but here's what I got:
I also tried a service that just proofread and fixed grammar . It was fine for final polish, but if your essay needs STRUCTURE help, this won't cut it.
My verdict: The best college application essay writing service isn't the cheapest or the most famous. It's the one where you actually connect with a real human who understands that YOUR voice matters more than fancy vocabulary. Don't let anyone write your essay for you—let them help YOU write it better.
Anyone else have experiences to share?
When I was applying to colleges last year, I spent weeks (maybe too many weeks) comparing the best college application essay writing services because I wanted to make sure I didn't waste my有限的 budget.I tried a few different approaches and wanted to share what I learned for anyone currently in the trenches:
Type 1: Big Platforms with Mystery Writers
Some of the large services I tried felt like a factory. I uploaded my essay, got edits back from someone I never met, and the comments felt generic. "Great point here!" without any real guidance. The price was low ($50-$100), but the value was low too. You get what you pay for.
Type 2: Individual Consultants with Real Experience
This was a game-changer. I found consultants who had actually worked in admissions offices or were professional writers . Yes, it was more expensive (think $200-$500 depending on the package), but here's what I got:
- A Zoom call where we actually talked about my story
- Edits in Google Docs with comments explaining the why behind changes
- Help brainstorming supplemental essays that connected to each school
I also tried a service that just proofread and fixed grammar . It was fine for final polish, but if your essay needs STRUCTURE help, this won't cut it.
My verdict: The best college application essay writing service isn't the cheapest or the most famous. It's the one where you actually connect with a real human who understands that YOUR voice matters more than fancy vocabulary. Don't let anyone write your essay for you—let them help YOU write it better.
Anyone else have experiences to share?